|First aired:||November 19, 2007|
|Written by:||Joe Pokaski|
|Directed by:||Greg Yaitanes|
|Previous episode:||Four Months Ago...|
|Next episode:||Truth & Consequences|
- Noah tries to save Claire and his family.
- Hiro attempts to save his father and learns a horrible truth.
- Matt turns to his ability to get what he wants.
- Elle, Bob, and Mohinder go on a mission.
|Kaito's funeral · Telepathy · Costa Verde hotel · Series of eight · Imperial Beach parking lot · Ishi's funeral · Victoria Pratt|
The Bennets are packing in preparation for leaving their home, when Claire comes down the stairs, dressed in her cheerleader outfit. When she starts getting ready for school, her father starts to argue with her about the fact that they are leaving Costa Verde that day, but Claire refuses to listen to him. Noah threatens to do something if she doesn't change her outfit, but Claire interrupts him, mocking him about his former days with the Company and attacking him on how they will never stop running. Noah then threatens to tie Claire up, but Sandra steps in and says that Claire can say goodbye to her friends at school but they are leaving that night.
At Kaito's funeral at Aoyama Cemetery, Hiro is called up to deliver a eulogy in his father's honor. He walks up to the podium, but then quickly walks away without saying anything. Ando meets up with him and asks if he's okay. Hiro replies that he came back too late, that they don't even know who the murderer was and that it is all his fault. Ando then urges him back to the podium saying that it isn't his fault. Hiro refuses saying if he does, then he is accepting that his father is gone. He then teleports back one week ago to when his father was killed.Matt is looking at the picture of the group of twelve when Molly walks in. He gets up to make her some cereal, but she inquires at the picture he was looking at. He says it's a "puzzle" and that they fit together somehow, but Molly interrupts saying that she can find them for him. He hastily refuses saying that he made that mistake before and that he just wants her to be a normal girl. She protests but he insists for her to be a normal girl. When she persists, he uses his power to project a plea into her mind. She agrees and walks off but he then uses his power again to make her come back to finish her cereal, to which she immediately does.
Mohinder meets Bob at a Costa Verde hotel. Mohinder wonders how they will kidnap Claire and Bob says they'll do it quickly and take out Noah in the process. Mohinder protests to any killing but Bob says it's just a phrase and that he's made the right choice. He then says that he needs a new partner and introduces him to his daughter, Elle. Bob then asks Elle if she's been working on her "sharpshooting", and she aims her hand like a gun and fires a small spark at a nearby glass, destroying it and lighting it on fire. Mohinder is shocked at her accuracy, while Elle blows her finger just as if she had fired a gun.
Claire is laying out rocks in a pattern, when West appears and asks her what her deal is. They then argue about where Claire's heart really lies, and Claire tells West she's just a cheerleader. West ponders whether the whole situation is just a big coincidence and Claire nods. West then flies off after saying that he wants to believe her, but he doesn't. Claire's rock pattern spells out SORRY.
Matt is at work trying to get information on the Angela Petrelli case when Detective Fuller tells him that it's solved and to get off of it. Matt refuses and pleads with Fuller for more time, but he refuses. Matt projects a thought into Fuller's head, telling Fuller to give Matt 24 hours to work on the case. Fuller agrees to let Matt do so.
At the Bennet home, Noah and Sandra are discussing West and Sandra is shocked that Noah abducted him at such a young age. Noah then shows her the picture of him lying dead noting that Claire was right--everything is about him. He then shows her the picture of Mohinder firing a gun, saying that while he could be shooting at him, Mohinder is one of the good guys. He also tells her his urgency to find West.
Mohinder answers Noah's call to his cell phone. Noah asks if Molly can track down West for him. Mohinder says yes and Noah thanks him. Mohinder then walks back into his room where Elle and Bob are packing and says that they can use this to their advantage by feeding him a false location. Elle disagrees saying that changing a plan mid-stream is a bad idea, but Mohinder threatens to tell Noah everything if they don't do it his way. Bob relents and Elle passes Mohinder a gun.
One week ago on Charles Deveaux's rooftop, Hiro is listening to Kaito and Angela's conversation about their death threats. When Angela walks away, Hiro reveals himself to Kaito who becomes pleasantly surprised. Hiro tells him that he's been in the time of Takezo Kensei and that Kaito is going to die tonight. Kaito asks him how he knows this and Hiro tells him he's just come from his funeral. Kaito tells Hiro that is his fate then, but Hiro refuses to listen, saying that he will show him that he felt this way once, teleporting him and Kaito back in time.
Noah begins to leave the house, telling Sandra he can't just wait around. When he walks outside, West picks him up and flies him high into the sky. While in the air, West threatens to drop him and that he wants answers about Claire. Noah says that Claire lied to him so he must be pretty important to her. West hovers back down to Earth and crashes into the ground. Noah recovers first and pins West to the ground. While he has West pinned, Mohinder calls Noah saying that West is at the corner of Verbena and Palm. However, Noah is with West at the corner of Ocean and 4th. Noah lets West go saying that he needs his help.coach calls her over saying that someone named Mr. Bishop from the education commission wants to see her. It turns out to be Bob, who then proceeds to call her by her real last name, Bennet. Claire quickly runs away realizing he is someone from the Company.
Elle and Mohinder are waiting for Noah when Mohinder asks Elle if she's killed many people. Elle pushes off the question, saying that it isn't any of his business. Mohinder then says that he should talk to Noah alone first because he trusts him.
Noah arrives at the corner of Verbena and Palm, and Mohinder jumps into the back of his car, asking Noah to give them Claire because they need her blood. A shocked Noah tells Mohinder he's gone native and says that they will never get Claire. Mohinder then pulls out his gun saying that he must do what he thinks is right.
A frightened Claire runs back to her house and sees the painting of her dead father. She is then startled when she feels her mother's hand on her shoulder, but quickly warns her about Bob and asks about the painting. Bob then appears pointing a gun at both of them saying that Isaac was an incredibly skilled and accurate painter.
Noah and Mohinder stop behind the high school and Noah asks Mohinder who his partner is when Elle appears. Noah smirks at her saying that he definitely knows her. Elle starts manifesting her power and starts walking towards them but is surprised when Noah looks above her. She turns around and West tackles her into a car, knocking her unconscious. Mohinder aims his gun at Noah's head in a panic. Noah has a flash of the 7th painting in the series and immediately disarms Mohinder and points the gun at him, but West talks him out of firing. He then settles for kicking Mohinder in the chest.
Noah arrives back home to find Sandra bound to a chair. She tells him that Bob took Claire. Noah replies that he has got collateral. When Sandra asks what sort of collateral, West walks into the house carrying an unconscious Elle. Noah asks his wife if she packed Mr. Muggles's doggy bath yet.
Noah wakes Elle up by spraying her with a hose, who discovers she is chained to a chair with her feet in the metal doggy bath. Noah says that he needs to speak to her father and Elle asks Noah if he thinks this is her first day. She begins charging up a bolt, but she doesn't realize she is soaked. The electricity reverses and shocks her entire body, causing her to scream in pain. Noah tells Elle that he was there when they first brought her in, that her father experimented on her. He pities her for the testing they put her through. He tells her that he plans to trade her for Claire.
Hiro and Kaito appear seventeen years ago at Hiro's mother's funeral. When Kaito asks why he did this, Hiro replies that he needs to make him understand his pain. When Kaito still refuses to be saved, Hiro accidentally runs into his younger self, who tells him that he refuses to let his father die. Hiro is shocked and tells his younger self that they cannot play God. Instead he tells the young Hiro to listen to his father and learn from him. After the young Hiro is called away by Kaito, Hiro acknowledges that he was being childish and agrees to take Kaito back to face his fate. Before they go, the two men pay their respects to Hiro's mother.
Noah prepares to leave to trade Elle for Claire, when West insists on coming along, arguing that he is the quickest way of escape. Noah relents and attempts to give Sandra a gun, but she refuses and tells him that girls pick boyfriends that are like their dads.
Hiro and Kaito teleport back to the Deveaux rooftop where Kaito tells Hiro he has never time traveled before and that he is proud of him. The two men bid each other goodbye, hiding their tears before Hiro teleports away. Moments later, Kaito's killer emerges on the rooftop and shoves him over as Ando watches in horror. As Kaito and his killer go over the edge, time freezes and Hiro emerges from his hiding place, telling the frozen Ando that he was right that Hiro couldn't save his father, but he can learn who killed him. Hiro approaches the roof's edge and is shocked to recognize his father's killer: Takezo Kensei who he believed died when Whitebeard's camp was destroyed in 1671.
Matt visits Angela in jail. Angela mocks Matt, telling him that she is less impressed with his mind-reading abilities than she was with his father's. Matt uses his evolved telepathy to force Angela to tell the truth about who killed Kaito and about the last woman in the photo. Angela resists as hard as she can to not answer the last question, pleading with Matt that the woman only wants to be left alone. Matt persists, and Angela begins bleeding from the nose. Angela tells Matt if he forces this answer from her that he's not only as bad as his father, but he is him.
West, Noah, and Elle wait for Mohinder, Bob, and Claire to show up. When they do, Elle and Claire walk back to their respective parties. When West starts to fly away with Claire, Elle electrocutes her binds and unloads a blast of electricity upon West, hitting him dead center. West falls back to the ground with Claire using herself as a cushion for him. She begins to heal from the plummet. Elle charges up again to shock Noah, but he shoots her in the shoulder. She falls to the ground as her father runs to her aid.
West flies Claire back to her house. Claire tells West that the last thing she ever said to Noah was that she hated him. West says that she didn't mean it, but she says she did and walks in. West looks on as Claire tells her mother that Noah's dead, to which Sandra falls to her knees and breaks down in tears.
Back at Kaito's funeral, Hiro is again called on to eulogize his father, but he still refuses to do so, saying that if he does, he is accepting that he is gone. He then goes on about all the things his father taught him saying that his father lives through his teachings. Meanwhile, Mohinder sits in the back of a van holding the gun he used to kill Noah. Bob attempts to touch his daughter's shoulder affectionately, but she brushes him off with a look of distaste. Matt looks at the now fully-labeled picture of the twelve, mainly at the final name--Victoria Pratt. Hiro rubs off the red paint of his father's grave. Sandra sits against the refrigerator while petting Mr. Muggles as Claire and West cuddle in bed.
As Hiro finishes speaking, an IV of blood drips into the body of Noah Bennet, whose eye begins to heal, thanks to the blood. He comes back to life and gasps for air, sitting up in absolute shock.
"What are you gonna do? Tie me up?"
"If I have to."
"We have the power of gods. That does not mean we can play God."
"You've gone native!"
"Stings like a bitch, doesn't it?"
"I am Takezo Kensei."
"Yes. Yes. You are."
"They say girls tend to find boys just like their dads."
"No, her real dad -- you."
- - Hiro
"I need you to tell me the truth."
"The truth? The truth is that our generation mortgaged our souls to protect yours, show a little respect for that. Get over your daddy issues, and leave us be!"
- This episode featured a number of moments that reflected similar scenes in prior episodes from the first season.
- Isaac paints Peter dying at homecoming. It is fulfilled but he ends up living, which is the case with Noah in this episode. Both survive due to Claire's ability. Also of note is that both Cautionary Tales and Homecoming were the ninth episodes of their respective seasons.
- Matt's first use of his power in a persuasive fashion is to make Molly eat her cereal. In Six Months Ago, Eden used her power to make Matt go eat some donuts.
- Claire says to West, "I'm just a cheerleader." Claire said this to Peter in Homecoming. Also of note is that both Cautionary Tales and Homecoming were the ninth episodes of their respective seasons.
- When Mohinder is in the back seat of the car that Noah is driving, it reflects the scene in which they first meet in Genesis. In that scene, however, Mohinder was driving, while Noah was the passenger.
- When Noah heals and sits up on the bed, he says "Holy sh--" and his dialogue is cut to the to be continued screen. A scene similar to this occurred with Claire in One Giant Leap.
- This is the first episode to feature Claire wearing her Costa Verde cheerleading uniform, even though it was used in promotional images before the season had started.
- Victoria Pratt is also the name of an actress who was a main character in Fireworks Entertainment's television series Mutant X, which was distributed by Tribune Entertainment (WB Network) as well Fireworks (Global and International Networks) from 2001-2004.
- The song playing during Claire's cheerleader practice is "Nine in the Afternoon" by Panic at the Disco.
- Sandra tells Noah that "girls tend to find boys just like their dads." This is a reference to the well-known psychoanalytic theory called the Electra complex, a theory based largely on the work of Sigmund Freud.
- The word "SORRY" written in stones is a possible reference to the series finale of MASH.
- This episode starts a day after Out of Time as referenced by various characters mentioning the events of that episode happening the day before.
- For images from Cautionary Tales, see images from Cautionary Tales.
- For the transcript from Cautionary Tales, see the Cautionary Tales transcript.
- For storyboards from the scene in which West intercepts Elle, see here.
- For storyboards from the scene in which Mohinder and Noah face off, see here.